Aikido Westchester, NY - Martial Arts, Self Defense and Fitness

                                    - Westchester Aikido Blog
Want to discuss a topic?  Have a Question?  Ask us...
Topic/Question:
Back
Westchester Aikido Blog: Studies in martial arts training in general, and Aikido specifically.
On ki - History of the Term (first in a series of two articles)

Ki (or Chi - Chinese) are central to many martial arts.  In fact, two martial arts use the term in their name: Aikido and Tai Chi Chuan.  The notion of ki will be explored in two articles below, detailing the historical development and usage in martial arts training.

Before embarking on these two topics I first wish to tell a story.  I took a number of classes in Tai Chi where chi became a central topic of conversation.  On one occasion, the master said that people should not think about chi as if it is something special...it is like air...all around us.  Then, he replied to questions about the location of chi in the body, in the center of gravity normally assumed to be 2 inches below the naval.  He explained that the real center of gravity is in a central point on the left foot when one's weight is on the left foot, and in the same location on the right foot when their weight is on the right foot. Some time afterwards, he updated these comments and said the real center of gravity is in the nose.  Being Jewish, I naturally had to ask whether that particular instruction would apply equally to Jewish people as to say Chinese.  For example, in my case I was concerned about becoming top heavy...

On Ki: History

"The original idea of ki developed as a metaphysical principle in a number of Chinese schools of thought.  Ki was, for example, the essential principle of harmony, and it was the source of creativity expressed in the form of yin and yang (Lao-tzu), the vital fullness of life (Huai-nan-tzu), the courage arising from moral rectitude (Mencius), the divine force that penetrates all things (Kuan-tzu).

As a term, it was never clearly defined.  Sometimes it was equated to empty space (the void) or nothingness (Lao-tzu), at other times to the formative energy emerging out of chaos (Chuang-tzu).  It was regarded by some philosophers as the dualistic principle that structures the universe...this dualism evolved into the ki operating as yin and yang, darkness and lightness, from which arose the Five Elements Theory and the divinations of the Book of Changes."

In point of fact, I have heard ki equated to prana and even the Holy Ghost.

"The primary metaphysical principle of ki was introduced into Japan in the Nara (710-94) and Heian (794-1185) periods and generally upheld, but the introduction of Buddhist thought from India to China affected its meaning, due particularly to the idea of karmic retribution.

More significantly, the idea of ki combined with indigenous views of nature responsible for the cyclic process of growth, budding, flowering and the withering of plants and trees...

The most dramatic changes in the interpretation and application of ki began to take place with the rise of the samurai class from the late Heian period...reaching its apex in the early Tokugawa (1603-1868).  The samurai who faced constant threats of death in an age of warfare understood ki in terms of courage, shi-ki; will power, i-ki; vigor, gen-ki; and bravery, yu-ki.  They were also concerned with equanimity, hei-ki; and conserving energy, shu-ki; which attempted to prolong breathing, ki-soku, as a matter of life and death..."

Ultimately, O'Sensei discussed his ideas of ki: "...I saw clearly that human beings must unite mind and body and the ki that connects the two and then achieve harmony with the activity of all things in the universe."  Later, "When one unifies mind and body by virtue of ki and manifests ai-ki [harmony of ki], delicate changes in breath-power occur spontaneously and waza [proper technique] flows freely."

According to Kisshomaru Ueshiba, "[the unity of individual-universe] inherits the idea of ki held by the ancient Chinese masters... [the free, spontaneous expression of breath power] teaches that a person's breath controls his thoughts and bodily movements...The reason for Master Ueshiba's emphasis on the dual functioning of unity and spontaneous expression is that he saw the essence of ki as being the essence of his budo."

[Quotations above from Spirit of Aikido by Kisshomaru Ueshiba pg 21-25 - [bold brackets my own]]

As Aikido continued to develop, unfortunately, the term ki became a political football.  Koichi Tohei, a top student of the founder, separated from the founder's organization (Aikikai) a few years after his death and formed his own style of Aikido, called sometimes ki-Aikido or Aikido with mind and body coordinated.  During his years under the founder, he was known for giving detailed and clear explanations of ki.  While O'Sensei gave primarily mystical explanations, Koichi Tohei explained ki almost as a mathematical formula, easily understandable by contrast.  The Aikikai responded by virtually writing Koichi Tohei out of the history of the organization and cleansing the term ki out of the records of instruction.  Meanwhile, Koichi Tohei's trademark became the ki of his Ki-Society, and while many aikido masters left the Aikikai for his organization in the early 1970's, they all left in droves beginning in the 1980's.  Fumio Toyoda Sensei was one who followed this path, later to rejoin the Aikikai.  We now have the relics of this political strife in our midst.  For years training under Sugano Sensei, the term ki was never to be heard.  It simply developed naturally with practice and there was no need to discuss it.  Under Toyoda Sensei the training left from Koichi Tohei, considered to be a valid method, continues on only absent the word ki as it is replaced by the term energy in daily practice.

When asked once about all the different teachers in Aikido and their political strife, Sugano Sensei wryly commented how strange it must seem to outsiders for us to call Aikido the art of peace.  They then observe how we all fight vehemently over who is teaching the real art of peace.

2006-09-16 02:35:30 GMT
Comments (4 total)
Author:Anonymous
I see the irony in Sugano-sensei's statement. I've not been a strong believer in any organized Western religion for a long time for similar reasons - differing opinions over who's practice is the "true" practice, and the politcs which ensues as a result. While aikido appears to be generally peace-oriented, and showing concern for you opponent's well-being is often emphasized, the political strife present in aikido today (at least in this country if not elsewhere) is a little disheartening to me. It's not enough to turn me from the practice altogether, but it does leave me concerned for its future. I don't expect a reunification of the various "branches" of aikido, but I would hope for a state of peaceful coexistence and cooperation at the least, where affiliations become minor concerns at most - a state of affairs much more in the spirit of aikido as I see it.
--D, the aikidoka
2006-09-16 06:42:50 GMT
Author:Anonymous
Do the techniques in aikido promote the flow of Ki? How?
2006-09-16 10:49:25 GMT
Author:Steve
"Do the techniques in aikido promote the flow of Ki? How?"

Could you do me a favor and read the next section. The material is related, and perhaps you have some other questions. Thanks.

Steve
2006-09-16 23:52:00 GMT
Author:Steve
D, the aikidoka

It is important to consider where political strife comes from and what it means in order to put it into the proper perspective...

Unfortunately, we live on a large planet with an enormous variety of people. I have heard it said that we should not even have as an objective that all the poeple on this earth should believe in one religion. There are just too many people with too diverse a set of dispositions to all simply accept one universal religion. That said, the nature of religion seems to be to maintain the attitude that it is the best religion of all the choices. Therefore everyone should believe in only that religion. It would seem we are set up for some pretty interesting conflict; given the history of human kind, we can also observe many of the conflicts that actually have and are taking place.

Given this backdrop, let us take an example. Consider Christianity as a religion. I do not have much education on the subject, so I appologize to anyone more knowledgeable for any errors. As I understand it, Jesus is considered the savior. If one accepts him and believes in him, heaven is a possibilty. However, rejecting Jesus in this lifetime invariably leads to spending the rest of eternity in hell. A Christian not only believes that their religion is best, but there is actually some urgency to the matter. They want to help you avoid an eternity in hell, and they don't have the luxury of waiting for your next life.

Quite often, this sort of thinking is behind the interreligious strife we see in our daily lives. While this sort of conflict is not ideal, disagreements born out of compassion (obviously excluding terrorism and such) is certainly better than many forms of conflict we see in the world that does not include interreligious strife. Consider World War II as an example.

Now, in this country, there are certainly many people who do not understand their own religions very well, and so their attempts to convert others turns into a more negative form of religious strife. The answer for them, as a starting point, may very well be to develop a better understanding of their own religions to reduce this negativity.

I suspect your difficulty with organized religion may be this version. What we see in Aikido is probably more similar to people with a high level understanding of their respective religions trying to convert others out of compassion, as discussed above. For high level practitioners who respond out of compassion but cannot agree on what is really best for others because of different belief systems, the problem isn't really so critical. I have heard it said that people who operate from a particular belief system should consider their actions within the context of what is best for others and society at large. To the extent their beliefs point them in the direction of destructive actions, they should reinterpret their beliefs so as to behave constructively. However, as an outsider to their belief system, getting people to reinterpret their beliefs may not be very easy. All told, this is not a really critical problem if observed within a broad context. People who step off the path of their religion and become hateful can be pointed back onto the path of their religion, and so these situations become learning opportunities for them.

Ultimately, rather than having a negative reaction towards people in either situation, as their final objective as practitioners of a religion in all cases is to become more compassionate and caring for others, we can simply help them appropriately in this endeavor. For my case, when dealing with a Christian who wishes to convert me, that invariably seems to be to smile kindly and exit the conversation as quickly as possible. There are so many other people on this earth for them to convert, they shouldn't waste their time with me:)..Hope this helps.

Steve
2006-09-17 12:03:25 GMT
Add to My Yahoo! RSS
Library:

The library contains extensive
writings, and so is available to
members only.  Members of the
dojo and interested parties
may register simply by
contacting us using the form
above.

Library Contents

Please pardon our appearance on
the library pages - we have
uploaded a significant amount of
material, but formatting and
organizing will take some time.  To
the extent you are interested in a
text or interview, the material is
available, if cumbersome.  Thank
you for your patience.

Suggested reading:


General
Art of War - Sun Tzu - Ancient
Taoist text on warfare and strategy.

Book of Five Rings - Miyamoto
Musashi - Known as one of the
greatest Japanese swordsmen,
text addresses strategic elements.

Tai Chi Classics - Various -
Ancient Taoist masters impart their
understanding of Tai Chi Chuan.

The Sword & the Mind Vol 1-3
by Yagyu Munenori

Consider also,
Zen and the Samurai - DT Suzuki
(two essays within
Zen and
Japanese Culture
); The
Unfettered Mind
by Takuan Soho

Aikido

Budo and The Art of Peace, by
Morehei Ueshiba,

The Spirit of Aikido  and Aikido,
by Kisshomaru Ueshiba

Best Aikido, by both Kisshomaru
and Moriteru Ueshiba

Takemusu Aikido Vol 1-5 and
Takemusu Aikido Special
Edition: Commentary on Budo
by Morihiro Saito

Ki in Daily Life  and Book of Ki by
Koichi Tohei (Combines Japanese
Yoga & Aikido)

Principles of Aikido and Aikido
and the Harmony of Nature
by
Mitsugi Saotome

In addition, for those interested in
the topic,
Zen and AIkido may be
an good text, by Kenji Shimizu and
Shigeo Kamata